Sign up to get new listings emailed daily! JOIN SIGN IN
Michele Matheis
REALTOR®
Facebook Icon 
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo
3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135 Photo

50 Total Photos [Click to View All]

$699,000
Status: Active
3864 N Us Highway 231 Greencastle, IN 46135
  • 4
    Bedrooms
  • 2
    Total Baths
  • 3,428
    Square Feet
  • 6.56
    Acres
  • 1879
    Year Built
  • HOA

Property Description

Step into a piece of Indiana history with the beautifully restored 1879 O'Hair House, a remarkable rural estate set on 6.56 picturesque acres just minutes from Greencastle & the renowned DePauw University campus. Offering nearly 3,500 square feet of living space, this stunning 4-bedroom, 2-bath residence seamlessly blends historic charm with modern convenience. From the moment you enter the impressive two-story foyer, you'll be captivated by the grand wooden staircase & timeless architectural details. Spacious rooms throughout the home feature exposed brick walls, soaring ceilings, & beautiful hardwood floors that showcase the craftsmanship & character of a bygone era. Thoughtful updates include a modernized kitchen & bathrooms, a whole-house UV well water system, & Verizon 5G internet service, providing the comforts today's buyers expect while preserving the home's historic integrity. Outside, a classic wraparound porch offers the perfect place to relax and take in breathtaking sunsets, peaceful countryside views, & abundant wildlife. Beyond the main residence, the property includes a charming carriage house/in-law cottage complete with its own bedroom, bathroom, & living area-ideal for guests, extended family, or rental opportunities. Adding even more versatility is the fully finished event barn/school building, featuring three classrooms, a large assembly room, and separate boys' & girls' restrooms. Whether envisioned as an event venue, educational space, retreat center, studio, or income-producing enterprise, the possibilities are endless. A tranquil pond on the south side of the property further enhances the estate's natural beauty & appeal. Rich in history, meticulously restored, and offering incredible flexibility for personal enjoyment or additional income potential, the O'Hair House is a truly one-of-a-kind property that rarely becomes available. This is your opportunity to own a landmark estate where historic elegance meets modern country living.

Michele Matheis

Email Me My Website

Request Info / Schedule Showing

Contact Form

Listed By / Shown By

Listed By

Broker Name: F.C. Tucker West Central
Agent Name: Chad Hess
Broker Phone: 765-362-4700

agent picture

Shown By

Agent Name: Michele Matheis
Agent Phone:
Broker Title: Cressy & Everett Real Estate

IDX logo

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS

Property Features

MLS Number: 202624096
Subdivision:
County: Putnam
Bedrooms: 4
Total Square Feet: 3,428
Style: Traditional
New Constuction: No
Construction: Brick
Waterfront: Yes
Property Type: Residential - Single Family
Basement: Yes
Basement: Crawl, Partial Basement, Unfinished
Cooling: Central Air
Fireplaces: 2
Garage: 2
Heating: Propane
Lot Size: 6.56 Acres
Stories: 2.0
Taxes: $3,162
Year Built: 1879

Feature Descriptions

Above Grade Finished SQFT: 3428
Amenities: Breakfast Bar, Foyer Entry, Porch Covered, Formal Dining Room, Main Floor Laundry
Days on CressyEverett.com: 41
Exterior: Brick
Fireplace: Family Rm, Wood Burning
Home Style: Traditional
Lot: 6-9.999
Lot Dimensions: 6.56 acres
Number of Rooms: 12
Sale Inclusions: Refrigerator, Cooktop-Gas, Water Heater Gas
Sewer: Septic
Total Finished SQFT: 3428
Water: Well

Room Sizes

Bedroom 1: 15x9 Level - Main
Bedroom 2: 16x8 Level - Upper
Bedroom 3: 13x13 Level - Upper
Bedroom 4: 14x15 Level - Upper
Dining Room: 18x18 Level - Main
Family Room: 16x13 Level - Main
Kitchen: 16x13 Level - Main
Living Room: 15x14 Level - Main
Laundry: 18x8 Level - Main

Location

Estimate Your Payment

Estimated Payment

$ 3,928.67 per month $3,461.30 Principal & Interest $263.50 Property Tax $203.88 Homeowner's Insurance

Change Payment Information

%
years/fixed
yearly
yearly (est.)
(Payments are an estimate and may vary by lender)
Note: a subscription to the Do Not Call list does not apply when requesting information from our company.

Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 07/29/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 07/29/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Wed 07/29/2026 12:23:10 AM EST) or MichRic (Michigan Regional Information Center) (last updated Tue 07/28/2026 11:17:48 PM EST) or NIRA MLS (last updated Tue 07/28/2026 11:04:47 PM EST) or IRMLS (last updated Tue 07/28/2026 11:12:17 PM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Cressy & Everett Real Estate may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility

Agency License Information: Cressy & Everett Real Estate is licensed in the states of Indiana and Michigan.



Agent License Information: Michele Matheis is licensed in the state of Indiana.

Login to My Homefinder